The profile is valid. The 1SG is taking on a lot of risk by not recognizing it and forcing the Soldier to do PT. The Soldier went to the military physician he was told to. Think of the Joint Commands that are around the world.
Profiles are recommendations that the Commander can choose not to follow; however they take the risk of the Soldier being hurt.
In this situation, if the Soldier is being forced to violate the profile, I would suggest speaking with or emailing IG if the IG office is not where the Soldier is located.
You might find this Related Post useful: Who can stop my leader from abusing me and ignoring my medical profile?