Bottom Line
There is no regulation that states you can be forced to attend a board. However it is definitely in your best interest to attend for several reasons.
Discussion
As an individual who was in this specific situation let me share with you my experience. First if given the order to attend and it is your place of duty then yes it is a requirement to attend. My BDE CSM gave me a counseling statement directing me to attend the Sergeant Audie Murphy board. So I told him you can make me show up but you can’t make me successful. I went to the board without studying then pride took over. I did well and passed. The Lesson I learned was that my senior NCOs knew what was best for me when I did not. Yes they got a feather in their cap but we all do when a Soldier that works with us does well.
Now let’s address this from a different perspective. Is it ethical to force a Soldier go before a board? Probably not if you want the letter of the law but what if your chain of command sees you as a high speed Soldier, worthy of recognition, and a standard bearer for the unit; should they force you to appear before a board? I would say “YES”. In my opinion it is ethical to make you appear. Your NCO support channel is being ethical in trying to mentor and grow the you.
You should in my opinion attend and do the best job possible. Represent yourself and the unit well. You reap benefits whether you win or not. You obtain experience, promotion points, a comment on your evaluation report, and potentially set yourself up for promotion in the secondary zone. I believe had I not gone to the board I may have regretted it and my NCO support channel may have remembered it when I needed someone to stand up and fight hard for me. Every action has an equal and opposite reaction. Leaders must be willing to build and grow leaders. This is the challenge now laid before you because the command believes in you. Your Soldiers are watching your actions and the example you set.
We obey orders unless they violate what I call the four unforgivable sins of leadership ILLEGAL, UNETHICAL, IMMORAL, UNSAFE. Just my two cents from a Soldier that has been there. Who knows one day in the near future you might see a high speed NCO or Soldier that you know needs to be recognized and represent the unit.
I hope you found this information useful
TOP
If you think this site is useful , follow us, and sign up for our newsletter
Please Read!
Comments
Anonymous
So I am etsing next month and my chain of command is saying I have to go to a “mandatory” promotion board. Is this correct? Can they actually force me to go even though my terminal leave form has already been signed? And the fact that I have my ETS orders.. it just doesn’t seem right to me..
Mark Gerecht
Can they Yes! Does it make sense? NO!
CHECKOUT OUR YOUTUBE CHANNEL: Mentor Military https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCj0IXu7SmA2wLoPrNAUfSZA
Hope this helps to some degree.
FOLLOW US
Facebook/Twitter/Newsletter
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/MentorMilitary/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Asktop/
Newsletter: http://eepurl.com/bjcYH
YOUTUBE: Mentor Military https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCj0IXu7SmA2wLoPrNAUfSZA
Twitter: https://twitter.com/AskTOP
Websites:
http://www.MentorMilitary.com
http://www.Asktop.net
http://www.ArmyCounselingOnline.com
Anonymous
I got an automatic P status and my chain of command is forcing me to attend the promotion board
Mark Gerecht
This response is provided based on the information you shared and should not be used as the sole source for making a decision. You should seek guidance from the chain of command, IG, JAG or other certified agencies before making any decisions. How you chose to use this information is totally up to you and is your sole responsibility.
There is no reason we know of that you should be required to go to the board other than board experience and you can get that from a Soldier of the Quarter board. In fact if you appear before the board and get a no-go then you will be removed from the list. This is a discussion you should consider having with the chain of command and/or IG as you don’t want to take the chance of losing your “p” status
Per AR 600-8-19, Par 3-24a, Soldiers integrated into the list are credited with all earned promotion points versus before where they had to attend a board in order to get all points.
The only advantage a Soldier may get from a board is the experience but that can be accomplished by attending a Soldier or the Month Board. Another situation that could occur is if the Soldier gets a no-go at the board, then what? Getting a no-go from a board is not one of the reasons for removal from the recommended list per Par 3-28.
CHECKOUT OUR YOUTUBE CHANNEL: Mentor Military https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCj0IXu7SmA2wLoPrNAUfSZA
Hope this helps to some degree.
FOLLOW US
Facebook/Twitter/Newsletter
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/MentorMilitary/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Asktop/
Newsletter: http://eepurl.com/bjcYH
YOUTUBE: Mentor Military https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCj0IXu7SmA2wLoPrNAUfSZA
Twitter: https://twitter.com/AskTOP
Websites:
http://www.MentorMilitary.com
http://www.Asktop.net
http://www.ArmyCounselingOnline.com